A recent study conducted by Carnegie UK revealed that a significant portion of the Scottish population has lost trust in the Scottish Government’s ability to enhance their lives. The report indicated that nearly 40% of individuals have doubts about Scottish Ministers, while around a third feel the same about their local councils.
Moreover, the research highlighted that there has been no noticeable improvement in the quality of life for the average person in Scotland between 2023 and 2024. This lack of progress was consistent across various measures, including levels of inequality, fuel poverty, and the capacity to handle unexpected expenses.
Carnegie’s Life in the UK Index, now in its second year, assesses the wellbeing of UK residents by analyzing responses related to social, environmental, economic, and democratic factors. The latest survey, conducted around the time John Swinney assumed office as First Minister, also revealed widespread distrust in political systems and institutions in the UK.
The findings indicated that a large majority of Scots feel powerless to influence decisions impacting the country, both at the UK and Scotland levels. Additionally, there were low levels of trust in the UK Government (60%), the Scottish Government (37%), and local authorities (31%).
Professor John Curtice from the University of Strathclyde emphasized the need for political leaders to not only address policy challenges but also to instill confidence in voters regarding their commitment to public welfare. The report identified specific demographic groups, such as individuals with lower incomes, disabled persons, and those aged 16-34, as having particularly low levels of wellbeing.
Furthermore, a significant portion of the Scottish population expressed concerns about safety in their neighborhoods, financial insecurity, and difficulties in keeping their homes adequately warm. The report urged policymakers in Edinburgh and London to collaborate in addressing inequality and improving the overall wellbeing of the people.
As Scotland commemorates 25 years of devolution, the report recommended initiatives like citizens’ juries to rebuild trust in politics. Sarah Davidson, the chief executive of Carnegie UK, stressed the importance of prioritizing people’s needs and using data on wellbeing to guide governmental decisions.
In conclusion, the study highlighted the pressing need for concerted efforts to tackle inequality, enhance public trust, and address the challenges faced by many individuals in Scotland. By focusing on key issues like job opportunities, community safety, and basic needs, policymakers can strive to create a more inclusive and prosperous society for all residents.
