The SNP’s plan to ban wood-burning stoves in new-build homes has been reversed, allowing future Scots to enjoy cozy fires during winter storms. The decision was met with praise from the Scottish Conservatives and the Scottish Islands Federation, who called it a victory for common sense.
The ban, part of the New Build Heat Standard regulations, faced backlash for its impact on rural areas where power outages are more common. Minister Kate Forbes raised concerns about the lack of practical solutions for these regions, highlighting the disconnect between policy-makers and rural communities.
The push to phase out wood-burning stoves in favor of ‘zero DEH’ systems was part of a broader effort to decarbonize buildings. However, the fast-tracking of these measures overlooked the unique challenges faced by rural areas, where staying connected to the grid is not always guaranteed.
The decision to lift the ban came after widespread power outages in rural Scotland, exposing the impracticality of relying solely on ‘zero DEH’ systems. The government’s reversal reflects a willingness to listen to rural communities, but also raises questions about the competency of policy-makers.
This U-turn is just one of many reversals by the Scottish government, including changes to emissions targets and other policy decisions. While flexibility in policy-making is important, too many reversals can erode public trust and credibility. Moving forward, the government will need to strike a balance between agility and competence to effectively address the needs of all Scots.
