Controversial Scottish Pantomime Draws Mixed Reviews
In a whirlwind of big bobby-dazzler song and dance numbers, the Festival Theatre in Edinburgh played host to a controversial pantomime production that left audiences divided. Mary Brennan, a respected reviewer, awarded the show three stars, highlighting the spectacle of costumes and special effects that dazzled the eyes of viewers.
A Disjointed Mix
While the production boasted magical moments that captivated both adults and children, Brennan noted that the show struggled to find a balance between traditional storytelling and modern variety show elements. The romantic narrative took a backseat to chaotic mayhem from the headlining talents, leaving some audience members feeling that the performance was not entirely family-friendly.
The Familiar and the Fresh
For Edinburgh’s panto regulars, the trio of Allan Stewart, Grant Stott, and Jordan Young brought a sense of nostalgia with their well-established chemistry on stage. However, the outdated jokes and innuendos may have missed the mark with younger viewers who did not catch the yesteryear references. Yet, moments of fresh energy, such as the dance-off sequence inspired by TikTok, injected a renewed vigor into the production.
Stewart’s Faerie May commanded the stage with unwavering energy, while Stott’s portrayal of Baroness Hibernia Fortuna delighted audiences with his growly charm. Young’s portrayal of Buttons added a touch of endearing daftness to the show, even if he didn’t get the girl in the end.
A Bittersweet Ending
As the action raced towards a two-hour conclusion, characters like Cinders (Amber Sylvia Edwards) and the Prince (Will Callan) delivered tuneful duets that enchanted the audience. However, supporting characters like the Fortuna Sisters, portrayed by Clare Gray and Gail Watson, seemed to be underutilized in the rush towards the inevitable happy ending.
In the midst of glittering costumes and show-stopping special effects, the controversial Scottish pantomime at the Festival Theatre in Edinburgh left audiences with mixed feelings about its blend of traditional charm and modern spectacle. As the curtain fell on this production, it was clear that while some elements shone brightly, others faded into the background, prompting discussions about the evolving nature of family entertainment in today’s world.
