The proposed generational smoking ban is sparking concerns among small retailers, who fear it could be a breaking point for their businesses. The Scottish Grocers’ Federation (SGF) has raised alarms about potential illicit trading and the impact on legitimate businesses if stringent enforcement measures are not implemented.
The UK-wide Tobacco and Vapes Bill, currently under consideration in Westminster, has been hailed by the UK Government as the most significant public health intervention in a generation. The bill aims to prevent those born after 2009, who will turn 16 this year, from ever legally purchasing tobacco products in the UK. Additionally, regulations on packaging, flavors, and product displays are set to be tightened, requiring retailers to make significant changes.
Industry Concerns
Dan Brown, a former president of the SGF and managing director of Lothian Stores Ltd, expressed his apprehension about the potential impact of the bill on small retailers. He emphasized the need for a balance between reducing smoking rates and supporting legitimate businesses, highlighting the challenges faced by compliant stores in the face of thriving illicit trade.
The SGF has raised concerns about the current fines issued for violations related to tobacco and vaping products, describing them as inadequate. With only a £200 penalty for selling or buying these products to under 18s, legitimate businesses are investing substantial funds to comply with regulations while illicit traders continue to operate with impunity.
Enforcement and Public Health
Dr. Pete Cheema OBE, chief executive of the SGF, underscored the impact of retail crime on staff wellbeing and the sustainability of local businesses. He called for more robust enforcement measures to address issues such as illicit trade and illegal distribution of age-restricted products to young people, which he described as shocking.
The proposed bill could also extend the indoor smoking ban to certain outdoor spaces, including children’s playgrounds and areas outside hospitals in England. ASH Scotland hailed the bill as a landmark step towards a smoke-free nation, emphasizing the need to curb the promotion of harmful and addictive products.
Public Health Minister Jenni Minto highlighted the bill’s focus on preventing children from starting to smoke, thereby reducing the likelihood of seeking out tobacco products illegally. She cited previous successful tobacco control measures that resulted in a decrease in illicit cigarette consumption. Minto emphasized the importance of collaboration with law enforcement agencies to address illegal sales and ensure appropriate sanctions for offenders.
In conclusion, while the Bill aims to promote public health by reducing smoking rates and curbing illicit trade, the concerns raised by small retailers about its potential impact on their businesses warrant careful consideration. As discussions around the generational smoking ban continue, finding a balance between public health objectives and the sustainability of small businesses will be crucial in shaping effective policies moving forward.
